If you’ve ever applied for a rental and wondered what’s actually being reviewed behind the scenes, you’re not alone. Many renters assume property managers are looking for one perfect number or a single red flag that decides everything. That’s not how it usually works. In Colorado, tenant screening is made up of a few core checks that help property managers understand risk and fit. None of them tell the full story on their own. And none of them make decisions by themselves.

If you’re applying for a home in Colorado, there’s a good chance you’re wondering how eviction history checks work and how much they matter. Evictions feel heavy, even when they happened years ago or during a tough moment that’s long passed.

This guide breaks down the most common screening errors, how to review your report, and what to do if something doesn’t look right. We’ll keep it clear, practical, and focused on Colorado rules, so you know where you stand and what steps you can take.