Rentell vs Portable Tenant: which Colorado report is right for you?

If you’re choosing between Rentell and Portable Tenant, start with what you need for your housing search: a complete report, a simple way to share it, and a price that leaves more money for your move.
Rentell costs $35 for 30 days of unlimited sharing. Portable Tenant’s regular prices are $56 for Silver and $59 for Gold. For a Colorado renter who wants to apply to several homes without counting report shares, Rentell offers the lower-cost option.
Price matters, but so does the experience of getting your report ready. Here’s how the two services compare, from reviewing your information to sharing it with a property manager.

This is Rentell’s comparison of our service with Portable Tenant, the company at portabletenant.com. Prices below are regular prices, excluding temporary offers, checked November 14, 2026.
Rentell vs Portable Tenant at a glance
Both services let renters prepare screening before a property manager requests it.
You’re choosing between two portable report services, not between a full report and a credit-check-only product.
Compare | Rentell | Portable Tenant Silver | Portable Tenant Gold |
|---|---|---|---|
Regular price | $35 | $56 | $59 |
Sharing period | 30 days | 30 days | 30 days |
Report shares | Unlimited | 2 | Unlimited |
Another 30 days | $25 refresh | Upgrade to Gold for $3 extra | $45 extension |
What are you paying for?
With Rentell, the $35 report includes identity, credit, income, criminal-history, and eviction checks. You complete the checks in your account, review the results, and share your report when you’re ready.
Portable Tenant calls its report MyRentsume. Its published workflow includes Experian credit information with VantageScore 4.0, criminal and eviction screening, income documents, and a rental application profile. Its plans differ in sharing features, rather than offering a cheaper credit-only tier.
Both cover more than credit. Compare the whole report and the way you’ll use it, rather than treating the higher price as a sign of better screening.
The price difference follows you through the search
At regular prices, Rentell is $21 less than Silver and $24 less than Gold. Gold is the closer comparison for someone applying to several homes because it includes unlimited sharing.
A new Rentell Report costs $35 for 30 days. If you’re still searching after that, you can refresh the report for $25 for another 30 days. That’s $60 for 60 days if your housing search needs it.
Portable Tenant lists a $45 Gold extension for another 30 days. Its published pricing doesn’t explain which checks are refreshed, so we haven’t treated it as a like-for-like report refresh.
You don’t need to know exactly how many homes you’ll apply to before choosing Rentell. Find the places that suit you, then reuse your report while it’s active.
A good renter experience means more than a fast checkout
You’re trusting a screening provider with personal information at a busy point in your life. The experience should make that easier, not leave you wondering what happened or what to do next.
See your information before someone else decides
With Rentell, you see the same report the property manager sees. You can understand the information in it and raise errors before sharing. There isn’t a separate property-manager-only version.
Portable Tenant also lets renters review their report and dispute inaccuracies. With either service, take that chance to check your details before they reach a property manager.
Share in a way that fits the application
Rentell gives you two options: invite a property manager securely or download a PDF to share directly. If one property wants a report invitation and another uses an application portal with an upload field, you have a way to handle both.
Portable Tenant also offers a secure link and PDF download. Its help page describes a recipient flow that includes signing in or creating an account and a one-time identity check. Its terms recommend platform sharing because it supports recipient verification and access controls.
Those controls can be useful. Portable Tenant also describes the ability to see report views and revoke online access. Revoking access won’t recall a PDF that someone has already downloaded.
For renters, the practical test is whether you can understand the report, share it without confusion, and get help when something isn’t right. Rentell brings those steps together around one reusable report, without a sharing-tier upgrade.
Leave enough time to review, not just generate
Portable Tenant advertises reports ready in around 15 minutes. We haven’t independently timed that process.
With either service, start when you’re preparing to apply rather than minutes before a deadline. Identity checks, income information, or an error you need to resolve can affect when you’re ready to share. A quick report is useful; a report you understand and have checked is more useful.
Colorado knowledge should make things clearer
Rentell focuses on making portable screening work for Colorado renters. That means explaining what your report does, how to reuse it, and what to do when an application process still asks you to pay again.
Colorado generally requires property managers to accept a qualifying PTSR and prohibits application fees or fees to access or use it. They can require a report completed within the previous 30 days and a statement that the relevant information hasn’t materially changed.
There’s an exception if a property manager takes no more than one application fee at a time for the home (or from each prospective renter or tenant group in a home rented to multiple occupants) and refunds it in full within 20 calendar days after either side declines a lease in writing.
Since January 1, 2026, Colorado law no longer allows a property manager to insist on delivery directly through a consumer reporting agency or third-party website. That matters when you’re sharing a qualifying report yourself. A provider’s preference for its own portal isn’t the same as a legal requirement.
The law sets requirements for the report, not a single approved brand. And accepting a report is different from approving a rental application: the property manager still makes that decision.
Our Colorado portable tenant screening guide explains the rules and how to use your report when you apply.
What about Portable Tenant’s acceptance guarantee?
Portable Tenant offers a report acceptance guarantee with a claim process. Its terms require evidence and contact information for the parties who didn’t accept the report, along with following the support team’s instructions. That may be useful protection if you run into a refusal, but it isn’t a guarantee of rental approval.
Which should you choose?
Choose Rentell if you want a Colorado-focused report with straightforward pricing, unlimited sharing, and the ability to review what property managers will see. The $35 starting price and $25 refresh keep the cost clear even if finding your next home takes longer than expected.
Portable Tenant is worth considering if its portal features, such as report-view tracking and online access controls, are important to you. Look at the plan you need and its current terms, rather than assuming every feature comes with the lowest price.
We built Rentell to make screening a useful part of your search, not another hurdle. Prepare once, see your own information, and share it with the next home on your list.
FAQs
Is Portable Tenant the same as a portable tenant screening report?
No. Portable Tenant is a company. A portable tenant screening report, or PTSR, is the type of report. Rentell and Portable Tenant both offer services in that category.
Can I use a Rentell Report at more than one property?
Yes. You can share your Rentell Report across multiple Colorado applications during its 30-day period. You don’t pay Rentell again for each property.
Can I see the report before sharing it?
Yes. Both services let you review your report. With Rentell, you see the same report the property manager sees, so you can check the information before sending it.
Do I have to buy from the company a property manager recommends?
A recommended provider isn’t the only possible provider. Where Colorado’s PTSR rules apply, the report must meet the legal requirements, but the law doesn’t name one company you have to use. Ask where to send your qualifying report before paying for another screening.
Get your report ready for your next home
Create your Rentell Report for $35. Review it, share it, and reuse it for 30 days while you find the right place.
Still comparing? See our five-service Colorado PTSR comparison for other options.



