Rentell vs Reusable Tenant Screening Reports: Which fits your Colorado housing search?

Two portable reports. Two very different prices. A Rentell Report costs $35 for 30 days. Reusable Tenant Screening Reports costs $59.95 for the same initial period. If your search runs longer, the price gap grows.
But a report needs to do more than save money. You want to understand what’s in it, get it ready when you need it, and share it without a headache.
Here’s how the two options compare for Colorado renters. We’re Rentell, so this is our take, with the differences laid out for you to judge.

At a glance
Compare | Rentell | Reusable Tenant Screening Reports |
|---|---|---|
Initial 30 days | $35 | $59.95 |
Additional 30 days | $25 refresh | $59.95 new report |
Total 60 day cost | $60 | $119.90 |
Sharing options | Secure invitation and PDF | Secure invitation and PDF |
Sharing | Unlimited in 30 days | Unlimited on homepage; 150 in FAQ |
Prices and published features checked November 14, 2026. “Reusable Tenant Screening Reports” (RTSR) here means the provider at reusabletenantscreeningreports.com, not reusable reports as a general category.
The price difference is worth paying attention to
With Rentell, you keep $24.95 in your pocket on the first report. That’s money you can put toward the move instead of spending more on screening.
A new Rentell Report costs $35 for 30 days. If you’re still searching after that, you can refresh the report for $25 for another 30 days. That’s $60 for 60 days if your housing search needs it.
RTSR’s published renewal process requires another application and another $59.95 payment. Two successive 30-day reports cost $119.90, compared with $60 for Rentell’s initial report and refresh.
You don’t need to buy a second period upfront with Rentell. Start with the report you need now, then refresh if you’re still looking.
A better experience starts before you share
Imagine finding a home you like and then discovering a mistake in your screening report. It’s much easier to deal with that before you’re ready to apply.
Rentell lets you build your report ahead of an application and review the same report the property manager sees. You can understand the information, spot surprises, and ask for help before sharing it. There isn’t a separate property-manager-only version.
RTSR’s FAQ gives mixed signals about the order of events: it says a property manager must accept an invitation before reports are generated, but also says renters can review generated reports before sharing. That leaves the initial review process unclear.
For us, renter control means being able to prepare first, rather than making a particular property the starting point. Speed matters, but so does knowing what’s happening and what you’re sending.
Sharing: both offer more than one route
Both services advertise secure invitations and downloadable PDFs. That’s useful because property managers don’t all use the same application process.
With Rentell, invite a property manager securely or download your report and send it directly. Unlimited sharing is included during your 30-day report period.
RTSR’s homepage advertises unlimited sharing, while its FAQ says up to 150 recipients in 30 days. Either is more than most renters need; the two descriptions simply don’t match.
The practical question isn’t whether you’ll apply to 150 homes. It’s whether you can easily get your report to the places you do want to apply.
What you’re paying for
A Rentell Report brings together identity, credit, income, criminal history, and eviction checks. You’re buying a reusable screening report, not just a credit score or a folder of documents to assemble yourself.
RTSR uses TransUnion data and advertises credit, criminal, eviction, identity, income, and rental-history checks. It also says its screening does not involve a hard credit inquiry.
The bureau’s name is one part of the decision, not the whole experience. Look at the complete report, how you’ll review it, and how you’ll use it during your search.
Colorado compliance isn’t exclusive to one company
RTSR’s website presents landlord statements that its report is the only truly state-compliant option. Colorado law does not name an exclusive provider. The report’s contents and the legal requirements matter, not the brand on the cover.
A qualifying PTSR includes consumer-reporting-agency information, employment and income verification, rental history, and other required screening information. Credit history, a credit score, and adverse credit events are not required for renters using a housing subsidy.
Generally, property managers must accept qualifying reports without charging application or report-access fees. They may require a report completed within the previous 30 days, free access, and your statement that relevant information hasn’t materially changed.
A narrow exception applies when a property manager takes only one application fee at a time for the home, or per prospective renter/group in shared occupancy, and refunds it in full within 20 calendar days after either side declines the lease in writing.
Our Colorado portable screening guide explains the rules in plain language. Knowing your rights should make applying easier, not send you down a legal rabbit hole.
Which would we choose?
For a Colorado renter who wants to prepare, review, and reuse a report at a lower cost, we’d choose Rentell. That’s the experience we built it for.
RTSR is another Colorado option with TransUnion-powered screening, flexible sharing, and advertised local phone support. Those are real strengths, but its higher price doesn’t create an exclusive right to acceptance.
Rentell’s case is straightforward: $35 to start, your report to review, unlimited sharing, and a $25 refresh if you need more time. You can spend less on the application process and more energy finding a place that feels right.
Frequently asked questions
Is Rentell cheaper than Reusable Tenant Screening Reports?
Yes. The initial 30-day report is $35 with Rentell and $59.95 with RTSR, a $24.95 difference. If you need another period, Rentell’s $25 refresh brings your total to $60.
Can I share my Rentell Report with more than one property manager?
Yes. Share it as many times as you need during its 30-day period. You can send a secure invitation or download a PDF, depending on how you want to apply.
Does a more expensive report give me a better chance of getting the home?
Price alone doesn’t tell you that. A report helps a property manager assess your application; it doesn’t make the decision for them. Choose a report you can understand and use, rather than paying more because a bigger price sounds more official.
Should I prepare my report before I find a home?
It can help to have it ready when you’re actively looking. You’ll have a chance to review the information before applying. Time it around your search so you can make good use of the 30-day period.
Still comparing options?
Our five-provider Colorado comparison covers the wider market. If these are your final two, Rentell gives you a lower starting price and a lower-cost way to keep going.



